Showing posts with label Satire. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Satire. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

Innocent humour...simpler times !

Purane Gunah Naye Gunahgaar

A mini review and discussion on the presence of humour and understated satire in SMP's work -- in simpler times !


Purane Gunah Naye Gunahgaar by Surender Mohan Pathak
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This mini-novel was written in 1963, yet doesn't feel much dated today. In fact it is quite a well paced whodunit-thriller interlaced with lovely humour that fits quite organically in the story. And the humour is not of the slapstick version, so common in whodunits, but has rather suave feel to it. The principal character, Sunil, is smart, vulnerable and a really charming character, who is always ready with a quip on his lips and a twinkle in his eyes. And although the murder actually happens well into the second half of the novel, you won't find a single uninteresting paragraph throughout primarily because the length of the novel itself is quite short and the pace is good.
But the real soul of the novel is the language that the characters speak : the classical Hindustani of 1960's era! What lovely words suffused with all the innocence and simplicity of a bygone era! You start suspecting that all the characters have just came back from a 'mushayra' or a 'kavi goshthi'. And add to that the innocence and charm of the 60's, which spills out of the demeanour of the characters here and engulfs you as well. How can you not fall in love with such people ?!

The only niggle that I had with the novel was that for such good buildup, the ending was a bit rushed and did not do justice. Also the speed at which some of the investigative actions were conducted in the novel ( especially for the 60's era ) require some suspension of disbelief. Apart from that a very enjoyable read, if not for anything else then at least for the nostalgia factor and as a remembrance for much simpler times!

View all my reviews


A mini discussion to follow-up :


विशेषकर जिस पक्ष ने मुझ पर गहरी छाप छोड़ी वो था नॉवेल का ह्यूमर जो काफी organically कहानी का हिस्सा बनता है, और ६० के दशक की simplicity ओढ़े हुए लगता है।

कहानी में कई  खिलंदड़पन से भरपूर वाक्ये होते हैं जैसे  सुनील और ब्लास्ट के चपरासी के बीच में नोकझोक , जहां चपरासी अपनी हाज़िरजवाबी से सुनील को लाजवाब कर देता है। पर गौर करने वाली बात है कि इन सभी जवाबों, सवालों और प्रसंगों में एक सरलता और मासूमियत है, जो कि अब नहीं दिखती, न दिख सकती है। ये कुछ-कुछ इब्न-ए-सफ़ी के विनोद-हमीद की चुहलबाज़ियों की भी याद दिलाते हैं, लेकिन कई मानों में जुदा भी हैं।

साथ ही कहीं कहीं तो इतने understated और matter-of-fact तरीके से व्यंग्य किया गया है, कि वो और भी ज़्यादा असरदार हो जाता है। अब यही उदाहरण देखिये ---
"ब्लास्ट के दफ्तर में धराधड़ काम हो रहा था। सारा स्टाफ बाहरी दुनिया से बेखबर मशीनों की तरह काम कर रहा था। एडिटर रिपोर्टरों से शिकायत कर रहा था कि वे अखबार के लिए सनसनीखेज खबरें नहीं लाते और रिपोर्टर झल्ला के सोच रहे थे कि क्या एडिटर को मशीन में झोंक देने की खबर सनसनीखेज हो सकती है ?"
---
हास्य के साथ ही इसमे निहित irony ज़रा देखिये कि जिन साहबों को दुनिया की खबरें सबतक पहुंचानी हैं, वो ही दुनिया से बेखबर हैं !
ऐसे ही कितने ही प्रसंग, बिना वार्निंग के इस कहानी में प्रकट हुए, जिनके वजह से पढ़ने में और आनंद आया।

मुझे ऐसा लगता है कि उत्तरोत्तर, जैसे जैसे सुनील का कैरक्टर बढ़ता गया, सारी कॉमेडी रमाकांत के हिस्से ही आ गयी, और ये subtle ह्यूमर वाला हिस्सा थोड़ा खो सा गया और साथ ही सुनील के खिलंदड़पन की जगह स्मार्ट-टौक ने ले ली। खैर समय भी तो ६० के दशक वाला नहीं रहा!

Sunday, March 10, 2013

Animal Farm : some thoughts


Animal Farm

My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This is one of those must-read books that actually lives up to its reputation. Though one would appreciate the satire in the narrative much more if he is well acquainted with the Russian political history after the Bolshevik Revolution, nevertheless, reading it otherwise is no less enjoyable by any means. The only issue could be the over-the-topness and lack of subtlety in the narrative but I guess it was essential when you are handpicking a few highlights from the sprawling history of a movement/nation and using it for mocking the movement itself.

The most memorable character is undoubtedly, Boxer, representing the hardworking peasant class. His story is the most heartbreaking.
And of course one of the most memorable one-liner : "All men are equal but some are more equal than others."



Friday, February 15, 2013

What actually is a SATIRE ? And what makes it effective and truly potent ?


We often think of satire as being some sort of twisted version of the reality, a parody of the 'real' thing. It won't be wrong to state that many a times we do not think of a literary or cinematic work to be having satirical content unless it consciously mocks at something : either a person, an institution or an idea. And to achieve that, many a times writers use absurd elements in their plots. And we accept that as a legitimate plot-device. Probably because we have this perception that being a satire, it has to be absurd and far from truth, and there is constantly a 'feeling' in us that 'reality' is something really dark and dirty and rough and that it is just too mature to be having any comical side to it.
So anything even remotely humorous has to be unreal and absurd.

In light of the above arguments, how refreshing it is to come across a new and revealing perspective shared by author Manu Joseph, in an interview recently, on the concept of humour and satire. This is what he had to say :

"One important thing I believe about humour is that at its core is accuracy. When you’re extremely accurate about something, it becomes funny."

So, in effect, he contends that if you are being uncompromisingly precise about something, to the fullest of detail without leaving anything, it becomes funny. Must say it is a really interesting viewpoint and sort of changes the way we 'believe' a satire or a work of comedy in general should be ! And if we think about it carefully there might be some merit in the argument too.
A classic satire such as 'Netaji Kahin' or 'Raag Darbaari' could be examples that actually lend support to the above point. In these works, the authors don't use a mocking tone throughout the narrative, to cater to our notions of what a satire should be. The tone, most of times is matter-of-fact without any conscious emphasis given on mocking. Nor is there, I doubt, any absurdity or 'unreality' included in the plots. I don't know if this is a representative sample of the genre or not but at least in these two cases the arguments of Manu Joseph seem to hold true. And effectively, it shows that life and 'reality' don't necessarily have to have a constant scowl on their faces, that they can possess a funny bone too. :)